Once you figure it out.. Its great!
I originally gave this a 2 star rating but i did not know how to fully operate. A better help screen would be nice and probably make it less painful to learn. I want more formations or custom formations option because my team plays a 3-5-2 and a 3-4-3. Also if there was an overall stats screen that showed the leaders in goals, assists, minutes, etc. that would be awesome. The stats screen at the end of a game wont scroll down, so if my teams score more than 4 goals I cannot see who scored or assisted. an additional slot for yellow cards and red cards, even a saves stat for goalkeepers, would be nice as well. If those things get fixed its a 4 1/2 to 5 star rating from me.